Stocked trout have minimal effects on littoral invertebrate assemblages of productive fish-bearing lakes: a whole-lake BACI study

摘要

1.Rainbow Trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss [Walbaum]) is commonly stocked as a sport fish throughout the world but can have serious negative effects on native species, especially in headwater systems. Productive fish-bearing lakes represent a frequently stocked yet infrequently studied system, and effects of trout in these systems may differ from those in headwater lakes. 2.We used a Before-After Control-Impact (BACI) design to determine how stocked trout affected assemblage-level and taxon-level biomass, abundance and average length of littoral invertebrates in a stocked lake relative to three unstocked control lakes in the boreal foothills of Alberta, Canada. Lakes were studied 1year before and for 2years after stocking. Because characteristics of productive fish-bearing lakes should buffer impacts of introduced fish, we predicted that trout would not affect assemblage-level structure of littoral invertebrates but might reduce the abundance or average length of large-bodied taxa frequently consumed by trout. 3.Relative to the unstocked control lakes, biomass, but not abundance, of the littoral invertebrate assemblage was affected indirectly by trout through increases of some taxa after trout stocking. At the individual taxon-level, trout stocking did not affect most (23 of the 27) taxa, with four taxa increasing in abundance or biomass after stocking. Only one taxon, Chironomidae, showed evidence of size-selective predation by trout, being consumed frequently by trout and decreasing significantly in average length after stocking. 4.Our results contrast with the strong negative effects of trout stocking on invertebrate assemblages commonly reported from headwater lakes. A combination of factors, including large and robust native populations of forage fish, the generalised diet of trout, overwinter aeration, relatively high productivity and dense macrophyte beds, likely works in concert to reduce potentially negative effects of stocked trout in these systems. As such, productive, fish-bearing lakes may represent a suitable system for trout stocking, especially where native sport fish populations are lacking.