A comparison of an evolvable hardware controller with an artificial neural network used for evolving the gait of a hexapod robot

摘要

This paper investigates the implementation of a novel evolvable hardware controller used in evolutionary robotics. The evolvable hardware consists of a Cartesian based array of logic blocks comprised of multiplexers and logic elements. The logic blocks are configured by a bit stream which is evolved using a genetic algorithm. A comparison is performed between an evolvable hardware and an artificial neural network controller evolved using the same genetic algorithm to produce the gait of a hexapod robot. To compare the two controllers, differences in their evolutionary efficiency and robot performance are investigated. The evolutionary efficiency is measured by the required number of generations to achieve an optimal fitness. An optimal hexapod controller allows the robot to walk forward in a straight line maintaining a constant heading and body attitude. It was found that the evolutionary efficiency and performance of the evolvable hardware and artificial neural network were similar, however the EHW was the most evolutionary efficient requiring less generations on average to evolve. Both evolved controllers were evaluated in simulation, and on a physical robot using a softcore processor and custom hardware implemented on a FPGA. The implementation showed that the controllers performed equally well when deployed, allowing the hexapod to meet the optimal gait criteria. These findings have shown that the evolvable hardware controller is a valid option for robotic control of a multilegged robot such as a hexapod as its evolutionary efficiency and deployed performance on a real robot is comparable to that of an artificial neural network. One future application of these evolvable controllers is in fault tolerance where the robot can dynamically adapt to a fault by evolving the controller to adjust to the fault conditions.