Facing the Irrationality of Duplicate Checking, How Do Journal Editors Review Articles in China?

摘要

The limitations and misjudgment of the duplicate checking software are presented by analyzing the duplicate checking of typical manuscripts. Problems of the irresponsible editors were pointed out in the process of preliminary examination of manuscripts. The significance and strategy of contemporary editors to regain the principles of "Three-Fair" (openness, fairness and justice) are elaborated based on the "real genius" paper fromJournal of Glaciology and Geocryologyand the famous "Pan Chang war" in the last century.