Gender Role Conflict Among African American Men Who Have Sex With Men and Women: Associations With Mental Health and Sexual Risk and Disclosure Behaviors

摘要

Objectives. We investigated whether high gender role conflict (GRC; internal conflict with traditional gender-role stereotypes and an individual’s perceived need to comply with these roles) is associated with psychological distress and HIV-related risk behaviors in a sample of African American men who have sex with men and women (MSMW). Methods. We analyzed baseline data collected from questionnaires completed by 400 MSMW participating in the Men of African American Legacy Empowering Self project in Los Angeles, California, in 2007 to 2010 for associations between participants’ GRC and experiences of poor mental health and HIV risk outcomes. Results. MSMW who reported higher levels of GRC than other participants also reported more psychological distress, lower self-esteem, greater internalized homophobia, less HIV knowledge, lower risk reduction skills, less disclosure of same-sex behaviors to others, and more unprotected vaginal or anal intercourse with female partners. Conclusions. Future research should consider how high GRC affects African American MSMW’s lives and identify specific approaches to help alleviate the psychological distress and other negative behavioral outcomes associated with internal conflict caused by rigid gender role socialization. Despite the heavy toll the HIV/AIDS epidemic has exerted on the lives of African American men who have sex with men (MSM), conspicuously few behavioral interventions have been developed to reduce HIV transmission in this population. 1,2 Behavioral HIV prevention interventions designed specifically for men of any race/ethnicity who have sex with both men and women (MSMW) are practically nonexistent. In response to a 2005 report of HIV prevalence as high as 46% among African American MSM, 3 the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and other funding agencies began making resources available to adapt existing HIV prevention interventions, developed originally for gay White men, and to design and evaluate theory-driven HIV interventions to address the specific prevention needs of gay-, bisexual-, and heterosexual-identified African American MSM. The Men of African American Legacy Empowering Self (MAALES) project, conducted in Los Angeles, California, is an example of a collaborative academic–community effort to develop and rigorously test a culturally appropriate behavioral HIV intervention for African American MSMW. 4 The critical thinking and cultural affirmation model, one of the behavioral theories underlying the MAALES small-group intervention, posits that a healthy integration of racial/ethnic pride, gender role, and sexual identity will allow African American MSMW to operate from a culturally rooted foundation to make healthier choices in their lives and relationships with sexual partners. This model recognizes that concerns regarding the preservation of African American masculinity underlie much of the conflict and discourse regarding male homosexuality and bisexuality in African American communities. A unique component of the MAALES intervention—aimed at reducing HIV acquisition and transmission risk behaviors—is its reliance on a culturally congruent framework that bolsters racial and cultural pride while reducing HIV stigma and gender role conflict (GRC). 4 GRC refers to negative consequences that can result from individuals' socialization regarding the roles ascribed to their gender and the need to comply with these roles. According to O’Neil, such consequences for men can stem from “negative critiques of self or others when conforming to, deviating from, or violating stereotypic gender role norms of masculinity ideology.” 5 (p363) Previous research on how males are socialized into traditional gender roles and the negative impacts of high GRC on mental health and other issues was conducted in samples primarily comprising heterosexual men. 6–9 With the exception of a recent investigation of the impact of high GRC on condom use in a sample of African American MSM, 10 most investigations of the impact of GRC on the lives of MSM have enrolled samples largely consisting of White gay-identified men. 11–13 In recent work to develop more effective HIV prevention programs for African American MSMW, Operario et al. conducted qualitative interviews with heterosexual-identified, behaviorally bisexual African American men to better understand the context of MSMW’s sexual behaviors with both male and female partners and the need for secrecy and confidentiality regarding same-sex behaviors. 14 The study findings revealed a high level of internal conflict among participants stemming from their desire for male partners in the context of community norms that valued rigid male gender roles, namely, an explicit expectation that “real” men will only partner with women. The investigators also found that participants emphasized the need to conceal their same-sex behaviors from female partners and members of their broader social network because of their p