Cork and talk: The cognitive and perceptual bases of wine expertise.

摘要

A number of previous studies have found that wine experts can more accurately discriminate between and describe wine samples than novices. This collection of studies is an investigation of whether the expert advantage is based on long-term memory structures, such as found for other obviously more cognitive skills, such as chess and bridge expertise.;Experiments 1, 2 and 3 investigated whether wine experts are better than novices in recall of wine descriptions. Experts showed more accurate recall than novices for descriptions configured in a meaningful manner, that is, consistent with grape varieties commonly grown in Australia, in both intentional (Experiment 2) and incidental tasks (Experiment 3).;Experiments 4, 5, 6 and 7 investigated the role of the above-mentioned long-term memory structures in expert descriptive ability. The results supported their involvement, since expert's ability to identify components was affected by sample configuration (Experiment 6), and novice descriptive performance improved when subjects were provided with a small set of grape-relevant labels (Experiment 4). However, while experts correctly identified more flavours than novices, they also made more errors (Experiment 6), suggesting that verbal longterm memory structures do not increase the relative accuracy of the identification of aromas and flavours by experts.;Experiments 8, 9 and 10 investigated both the discrimination performance of novices, intermediates and experts, as well as the role of long-term memory structures in any expert discriminative advantage. Experts (Experiments 8 and 10) and intermediates (Experiment 9) showed greater powers of discrimination than novices. However, results were equivocal in relation to the role of verbal long-term memory structures (Experiment 10), suggesting that other factors, such as perceptual learning and or memory, may be important in the expert discriminative advantage.;Overall, results from these studies illustrate that long-term memory structures are essential, not only in domains of expertise that are obviously based on cognitive skills, but also that of descriptive ability with respect to wine. However, unlike in other domains, these structures do not serve to improve the relative accuracy of descriptive performance, at least with regard to aromas and flavours.